Thyroid Disease in Pregnancy: Screening and Treatment Targets

Clinical Practice Update — Who to test, when to treat, which TSH target to aim for, and what the 2026 ATA guideline changed for obstetric care

This is an original clinical education article informed by current guidelines and evidence. See References below for source documents.

MDA-TDP-2026·14 min read
Clinical Focus
Screening strategy, diagnostic thresholds, levothyroxine and antithyroid drug targets, and postpartum follow-up for thyroid disease in pregnancy
Target Audience
Obstetricians, maternal-fetal medicine specialists, endocrinologists, family physicians, midwives, residents
Setting
Preconception clinics, antenatal clinics, fertility services, postpartum care
Source Evidence
  • •American Thyroid Association 2026 Guidelines for Thyroid Disease in Preconception, Pregnancy, and Postpartum (Thyroid, 2026)
  • •ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 223 — Thyroid Disease in Pregnancy (Obstet Gynecol, 2020)
  • •RCOG Green-top Guideline No. 76 — Management of Thyroid Disorders in Pregnancy (BJOG, 2025)
  • •CATS trial (NEJM, 2012) and MFMU Network levothyroxine trial (NEJM, 2017)
  • •TABLET trial — Levothyroxine in TPO antibody-positive women (NEJM, 2019)

What Changed in Practice

The 2026 American Thyroid Association guideline, endorsed by ACOG, reshapes how thyroid disease in pregnancy is found and treated, replacing reflexive levothyroxine with confirmed, trimester-aware decisions.1

→The fixed TSH cut-offs of 2.5 and 3.0 mU/L are gone as diagnostic thresholds; use laboratory- and trimester-specific ranges, or about 4.0 mU/L in the first trimester when none exist.1,12
→Mild abnormalities (TSH above the pregnancy limit but below 6 mU/L) should often be retested before treatment, because roughly half normalise within weeks.1
→Subclinical hypothyroidism is now judged by when it is found: treatment may be offered in the first trimester, but starting it later has not improved outcomes.1,5,6
→TPO antibody status no longer decides whether to treat subclinical hypothyroidism, and euthyroid antibody-positive women should not receive levothyroxine.1,7
→Universal screening is still not recommended; testing follows an updated risk-factor list that drops age, BMI, parity and a single miscarriage.1,2
→Iodine 150 mcg daily is now advised for all women from preconception through lactation, ideally starting three months before conception.1

Key Clinical Takeaways

Direct actions for thyroid disease in pregnancy, most practice-changing first.

Thyroid disease in pregnancy care pathway: targeted TSH testing, levothyroxine dose adjustment, and antithyroid drug choice by trimester
Thyroid disease in pregnancy: from targeted testing and confirmatory retesting to trimester-aware treatment and postpartum follow-up.
  1. 1Retest a mildly raised TSH (below 6 mU/L) within about three weeks before committing to levothyroxine, using shared decision-making → When Should Subclinical Hypothyroidism Be Treated?
  2. 2Stop prescribing levothyroxine to euthyroid TPO antibody-positive women for miscarriage or IVF outcomes → What About TPO Antibodies and Euthyroid Women?
  3. 3Tell every woman on levothyroxine to increase her dose herself — two extra tablets a week — as soon as a pregnancy test is positive → How Should Known Hypothyroidism Be Managed?
  4. 4Switch women on methimazole to propylthiouracil once they are actively trying to conceive → How Should Graves Disease Be Managed?
  5. 5Test TSH only in women with risk factors, not in every pregnant patient → Who Should Be Tested for Thyroid Disease in Pregnancy?
  6. 6Measure TRAb or TSI in the first trimester in anyone with a history of Graves disease, including after ablation → How Should Graves Disease Be Managed?
  7. 7Leave gestational transient thyrotoxicosis untreated with antithyroid drugs → Is a Low TSH Always Hyperthyroidism?

Why This Update Matters

Thyroid disease in pregnancy is common enough that every antenatal clinic sees it weekly: subclinical hypothyroidism affects about 3–3.5% of pregnancies and TPO antibodies about 9%.1 The old “treat anything above 2.5” habit left many women on lifelong levothyroxine for a transient result. The new approach protects the fetal brain where the evidence supports it — overt hypothyroidism, early-pregnancy subclinical disease, Graves antibodies — while sparing the rest from unnecessary tablets, anxiety and extra visits.

0.4–0.5%of pregnancies have new-onset overt hypothyroidism
3.2–3.5%of pregnancies have subclinical hypothyroidism
41%of untreated subclinical cases persist when retested about 3 weeks later
7–9%of euthyroid TPOAb-positive women develop hypothyroidism within a year

Who Should Be Tested for Thyroid Disease in Pregnancy?

ACOG and the ATA both reject universal screening for thyroid disease in pregnancy, because finding and treating subclinical hypothyroidism has not improved outcomes.1,2 The ATA has refined its risk-factor list instead, validated in commissioned cohorts.1

1

Do not perform universal thyroid function screening in pregnancy, preconception or postpartum.

AgainstHigh EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020ATA 2026
2

Evaluate every newly pregnant patient clinically for thyroid risk factors and offer TSH testing, ideally in the first trimester, to those at increased risk. Practice impact: build the risk-factor checklist into the booking visit rather than ordering TSH by habit.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026RCOG GTG 76 2025
3

Test women with known thyroid antibodies, personal or family history of thyroid disease, type 1 diabetes or other autoimmune disease, prior neck radiation or thyroid surgery, Down or Turner syndrome, thyroid-active medications such as amiodarone or lithium, or likely iodine deficiency.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026ACOG PB 223 2020
4

Test women with infertility or recurrent miscarriage if this was not done before conception.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
5

Measure TSH first, reflexing to free T4 when TSH is abnormal, and add total T3 when hyperthyroidism is suspected.

Strong RecHigh EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020
6

Avoid routine TPO antibody screening in euthyroid women without risk factors.

AgainstModerate EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020
Clinical Pearl: When screening for thyroid disease in pregnancy, remember that a diffusely enlarged thyroid is expected — volume rises by up to 30% — so a mild goitre alone is not an indication for testing. A distinct nodule or a clearly significant goitre is.2

What TSH Threshold Defines Hypothyroidism?

The biggest conceptual shift in thyroid disease in pregnancy is the explicit separation of diagnostic thresholds from treatment targets. The old 2.5 and 3.0 mU/L limits, used diagnostically, labelled many healthy women hypothyroid.1,12 In thyroid disease in pregnancy, TSH remains the most reliable marker because free T4 immunoassays drift with the binding-protein changes of pregnancy.1

1

Use laboratory- and trimester-specific TSH and free T4 reference intervals wherever they exist.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026RCOG GTG 76 2025
2

Consider a first-trimester TSH range of about 0.1–4.0 mU/L when local pregnancy ranges are unavailable; where the non-pregnant upper limit is well above 4.5 mU/L, subtract 0.5 mU/L instead. Practice impact: stop diagnosing hypothyroidism at a TSH of 2.6–4.0 mU/L.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
3

Prioritise TSH over free T4 when they conflict, and keep the same assay throughout.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026
Evidence note
A fixed 4.0 mU/L limit captured under half of true first-trimester overt hypothyroidism in one analysis, and whether this misclassification causes harm is unknown.1 Treat 4.0 as a pragmatic fallback, not a precise boundary.

How Should Known Hypothyroidism Be Managed?

Pre-existing hypothyroidism is the commonest thyroid disease in pregnancy seen in clinic. Women who are euthyroid on levothyroxine have fertility and pregnancy outcomes similar to women without hypothyroidism, so the job is to stay ahead of rising demand.1 Requirement typically climbs about 25% by week 12 and about 50% by week 20.1,9

1

Aim for a preconception TSH of 0.5–2.5 mU/L in women on levothyroxine who are planning pregnancy.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026ACOG PB 223 2020
2

Counsel women to self-initiate a dose increase as soon as the pregnancy test is positive — two extra daily doses per week, or a roughly 25% daily increase. Practice impact: give the instruction in writing at the preconception visit so the increase is not delayed until booking.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceRCOG GTG 76 2025ATA 2026
3

Temper the empirical increase when preconception TSH is below 1.5 mU/L or the dose exceeds 100 mcg/day, where overtreatment is more likely.

Conditional RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
4

Target a TSH within the pregnancy reference range and below 2.5 mU/L during pregnancy.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020ATA 2026
5

Switch women taking liothyronine or desiccated thyroid to levothyroxine monotherapy before conception, because the fetal brain depends on maternal T4.

Strong RecLow EvidenceATA 2026ACOG PB 223 2020
6

Anticipate an earlier or larger increase after ovarian stimulation for IVF and in twin pregnancies.

Conditional RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
7

Return to the prepregnancy dose at delivery and recheck thyroid function at six weeks.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
Clinical Pearl: Ovarian stimulation raises TSH by around 1.5 mU/L on average in women on a fixed levothyroxine dose, and that rise carries into early pregnancy.1 Check TSH at the start of an IVF cycle, not only after a positive test.

When Should Overt Hypothyroidism Be Treated?

Overt hypothyroidism is the form of thyroid disease in pregnancy with the clearest case for treatment. It is associated with miscarriage, gestational hypertension, preterm birth and lower offspring IQ, and treatment to euthyroidism appears to remove most of that excess risk.1,2

1

Start levothyroxine for overt hypothyroidism with TSH at or above 6 mU/L.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026ACOG PB 223 2020
2

Estimate the starting dose as full replacement (1.5–1.7 mcg/kg/day) plus a further 20–30% for pregnancy.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
3

Consider retesting mild overt hypothyroidism (TSH above the pregnancy limit but below 6 mU/L) within one to three weeks before starting treatment, if the patient prefers after counselling. Practice impact: mild overt disease is now handled much like subclinical disease rather than as an automatic prescription.

Conditional RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
Warning
Newly diagnosed overt hypothyroidism is not a medical indication for termination of pregnancy.1 Counsel that biochemical control with levothyroxine brings outcome risks close to those of euthyroid women.

When Should Subclinical Hypothyroidism Be Treated?

This is where thyroid disease in pregnancy practice has changed most. CATS (treatment from a median of about 12 weeks) and the MFMU trial (about 17 weeks) showed no gain in child IQ or obstetric outcomes.5,6 A smaller trial treating mostly in the first trimester suggested fewer preterm births, but only with a TSH cut-off above 4.0 mU/L.1

1

Offer levothyroxine through shared decision-making for subclinical hypothyroidism found in the first trimester, explaining both the modest risks and the uncertain benefit.

Conditional RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
2

Consider retesting within about three weeks before treating, especially when TSH is below 6 mU/L; if treatment is deferred, recheck within three weeks to exclude progression.

Conditional RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
3

Start a low dose of 25–75 mcg/day, guided by TSH and weight, if treating. Practice impact: avoid fixed high doses — overtreated CATS participants had children with more ADHD-type symptoms.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
4

Avoid routinely starting levothyroxine for subclinical hypothyroidism first found after the first trimester.

AgainstHigh EvidenceCATS 2012MFMU 2017ATA 2026
5

Postpone conception and repeat TSH after four to six weeks when subclinical hypothyroidism is found before pregnancy; start around 50 mcg/day if it persists or waiting is impractical.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
6

Plan a levothyroxine cessation trial after delivery for women treated only for subclinical disease.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
Clinical Pearl: In thyroid disease in pregnancy, the trimester boundary is pragmatic, not physiological. A woman booking at 13 weeks with a rising TSH can reasonably be managed as a first-trimester case — the guideline explicitly allows a few weeks of latitude.1

Matching the Result to the Action

TSH Result (with Normal or Low Free T4)Found PreconceptionFound in First TrimesterFound After First Trimester
Above pregnancy limit, below 6 mU/L, normal free T4Delay conception, retest in 4–6 weeksShared decision; retest in about 3 weeks or start 25–75 mcgDo not start routinely; manage expectantly
Above pregnancy limit, below 6 mU/L, low free T4Treat and titrate to 0.5–2.5 mU/LRetest in 1–3 weeks or treat, per preferenceTreat
6 mU/L or higher, normal free T4Low-dose levothyroxine without waitingShared decision, lean toward treatingIndividualise; evidence of benefit is weak
6 mU/L or higher, low free T4TreatTreat promptly with weight-based doseTreat promptly with weight-based dose
Normal TSH, TPOAb positiveNo levothyroxine; recheck TSH every 3–6 monthsNo levothyroxine; follow TSH through pregnancyNo levothyroxine

What About TPO Antibodies and Euthyroid Women?

In thyroid disease in pregnancy, antibody-positive euthyroid women carry a small excess risk of miscarriage (about 2–8% absolute) and preterm birth, but three high-quality randomised trials — including TABLET in women with prior miscarriage or infertility and a Chinese IVF trial — found no benefit from levothyroxine.1,7,8 The likely explanation is that antibodies mark a wider autoimmune tendency rather than a thyroid hormone deficit.1

1

Do not prescribe levothyroxine to euthyroid TPOAb-positive women, including those with infertility, IVF or recurrent miscarriage. Practice impact: discontinue “just in case” levothyroxine started for antibodies alone.

AgainstHigh EvidenceTABLET 2019ATA 2026
2

Recheck TSH every three to six months before conception in antibody-positive women, and follow thyroid function through pregnancy, since about 18% develop subclinical hypothyroidism in pregnancy.

Moderate RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026
3

Do not use selenium, corticosteroids or intravenous immunoglobulin to improve outcomes in antibody-positive women.

AgainstLow EvidenceATA 2026

Is a Low TSH Always Hyperthyroidism?

A suppressed TSH at the end of the first trimester is usually physiology rather than thyroid disease in pregnancy: hCG stimulates the TSH receptor, and a TSH below 0.4 mU/L is common in healthy pregnancy.1 Gestational transient thyrotoxicosis resolves as hCG falls and has not been linked to poor outcomes.2

1

Do not treat gestational transient thyrotoxicosis with antithyroid drugs; manage fluids and vomiting instead.

AgainstModerate EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020ATA 2026
2

Do not check thyroid function routinely in hyperemesis gravidarum unless signs of overt hyperthyroidism are present.

AgainstLow EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020
3

Repeat thyroid function every two to four weeks for a low TSH with normal free T4 and T3 until TSH normalises.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
4

Measure TRAb or TSI when overt hyperthyroidism persists, particularly beyond 20 weeks.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026
5

Do not treat subclinical hyperthyroidism in pregnancy.

AgainstModerate EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020
Clinical Pearl: Thyroid ultrasound does not help separate transient gestational thyrotoxicosis from Graves disease, because both act through the same receptor. Antibodies, eye signs and persistence beyond mid-pregnancy do the work.1

How Should Graves Disease Be Managed?

Graves disease accounts for about 95% of hyperthyroidism in pregnancy — the most consequential hyperthyroid form of thyroid disease in pregnancy — and poor control raises the risk of pre-eclampsia, heart failure, thyroid storm, growth restriction and stillbirth.2 Both thioamides are teratogenic, but methimazole defects (aplasia cutis, choanal and oesophageal atresia) are more severe.10,11

1

Discuss pregnancy plans with every woman of reproductive age newly diagnosed with Graves disease, and advise waiting to conceive until euthyroid on two sets of tests at least six weeks apart.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
2

Switch methimazole to propylthiouracil once actively trying to conceive; if propylthiouracil is unavailable, use the lowest effective methimazole dose. Practice impact: make the switch at the planning visit, not after the first missed period.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026ACOG PB 223 2020
3

Consider stopping antithyroid drugs at pregnancy confirmation in women euthyroid on a low dose after at least six months of therapy, with close thyroid monitoring.

Conditional RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
4

Titrate to the lowest thioamide dose that keeps free T4 at or slightly above the upper part of the pregnancy reference range, regardless of TSH.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020ATA 2026
5

Measure TRAb or TSI in the first trimester in all women with a Graves history — including after radioiodine or thyroidectomy — and repeat at 18–22 weeks if above three times the upper limit.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026
6

Arrange serial fetal ultrasound from 18–20 weeks when antibodies stay high or antithyroid drugs continue, looking for tachycardia, growth restriction, goitre or hydrops.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026ACOG PB 223 2020
7

Avoid radioiodine in pregnancy, and delay conception for at least six months after it.

Strong RecModerate EvidenceATA 2026
8

Reserve thyroidectomy in pregnancy for failure or intolerance of drugs, preferring the second trimester and a high-volume surgeon.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
9

Notify the paediatric team of maternal Graves disease and antibody status before delivery.

Strong RecLow EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020
Warning
Stop the thioamide and check a full blood count immediately if fever or sore throat develops — agranulocytosis occurs in under 1% of users, is not dose-related, and cannot be anticipated by routine counts.2 Propylthiouracil also carries a rare risk of severe hepatotoxicity.
Clinical Pearl: In thyroid disease in pregnancy after Graves ablation, radioiodine can push TRAb up for one to three years afterward, so a woman who is hypothyroid on levothyroxine after ablation can still carry a thyrotoxic fetus.1 Antibodies, not maternal thyroid status, set the fetal risk.

Drugs Used in Thyroid Disease in Pregnancy

Doses below are guideline-based starting points for thyroid disease in pregnancy; titration and the choice to switch agents after the first trimester usually involve endocrinology or maternal-fetal medicine and follow local protocol.

DrugIndicationDose (guideline-based)Target / MonitoringMajor Adverse EffectsPractical Notes
LevothyroxineOvert or selected subclinical hypothyroidismNew overt: 1.5–1.7 mcg/kg/day plus 20–30%; subclinical: 25–75 mcg/day; known disease: +2 doses/week at positive testTSH in pregnancy range and below 2.5 mU/L; every 4 weeks to mid-gestationIatrogenic hyperthyroidism if overtreatedSeparate from iron and calcium; back to prepregnancy dose at delivery
PropylthiouracilHyperthyroidism, preconception and first trimester100–600 mg/day in three divided doses; typical 200–400 mgFree T4 at upper end of pregnancy range; every 2–4 weeksHepatotoxicity; agranulocytosisConverts to methimazole at about 20:1 if switched
MethimazoleHyperthyroidism after the first trimester5–30 mg/day, once daily in maintenanceAs for propylthiouracilFirst-trimester embryopathy; agranulocytosisSwitching mid-pregnancy may briefly worsen control

Clinical Decision Pathway

A question-based route through thyroid disease in pregnancy.

Thyroid Disease in Pregnancy: Five Questions
Does she have a risk factor or symptoms?
No > do not test routinely.
Yes > measure TSH, reflex to free T4 if abnormal.
Is TSH high?
Below 6 mU/L > retest in 1–3 weeks or offer treatment through shared decision; weigh gestational age.
6 mU/L or more with low free T4 > start weight-based levothyroxine now.
Subclinical and beyond the first trimester > manage expectantly.
Is TSH low?
Normal free T4 and T3 > repeat every 2–4 weeks; most is gestational.
Raised free T4 with vomiting, twins or molar pregnancy > supportive care, no thioamide.
Persistent overt disease, eye signs or goitre > check TRAb and treat Graves disease.
Is she already on treatment?
Levothyroxine > add two tablets weekly at the positive test, target TSH below 2.5 mU/L.
Methimazole > switch to propylthiouracil in the first trimester.
Are TRAb or TSI more than three times the upper limit?
Yes > repeat at 18–22 weeks, arrange fetal surveillance, alert the paediatric team.

Who Needs a Different Approach?

Several groups need the standard framework for thyroid disease in pregnancy adjusted rather than replaced. Iodine-poor or plant-based diets raise the risk of maternal and fetal hypothyroidism, and amiodarone or iodinated contrast delivers an iodine load that can disturb fetal thyroid function, so weigh these carefully before use.1

1

Advise iodine 150 mcg daily for all women from at least three months before conception through lactation, aiming for a total intake of about 250 mcg/day. Practice impact: check that the prenatal vitamin actually contains iodine — many do not.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
2

Avoid iodine supplements above 500 mcg daily in pregnancy.

AgainstLow EvidenceATA 2026
3

Evaluate for fetal thyrotoxicosis and involve maternal-fetal medicine when a Graves history coexists with fetal tachycardia, growth restriction, goitre or hydrops.

Strong RecLow EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020
4

Treat suspected thyroid storm immediately in a high-dependency setting without waiting for results, using propylthiouracil, iodine given 1–2 hours later, a glucocorticoid and cautious beta-blockade.

Strong RecLow EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020
Warning
Thyroid storm is a clinical diagnosis. ACOG’s regimen starts with propylthiouracil 1,000 mg orally then 200 mg every 6 hours, with iodine only after the thioamide has been given.2 Use beta-blockers cautiously if heart failure is present.

Monitoring Thyroid Disease in Pregnancy and Postpartum

Monitoring is where good management of thyroid disease in pregnancy is either sustained or lost, and the postpartum year is part of thyroid disease in pregnancy care, not an afterthought. Postpartum thyroiditis affects about 5–10% of women, usually as brief thyrotoxicosis then hypothyroidism at four to eight months; a third develop permanent hypothyroidism.2 Graves disease in remission relapses after delivery in about 25–55%.1

1

Check TSH every four weeks until mid-gestation and at least once near 30 weeks in women treated for hypothyroidism.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026ACOG PB 223 2020
2

Check thyroid function every two to four weeks on antithyroid drugs in the first half of pregnancy and every four to eight weeks thereafter.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
3

Test thyroid function at 4–6 weeks and 4–6 months postpartum after Graves disease, or sooner if symptoms return.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
4

Treat the thyrotoxic phase of postpartum thyroiditis with a beta-blocker for symptoms, not with thioamides.

AgainstModerate EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020
5

Consider levothyroxine for the hypothyroid phase when symptomatic, breastfeeding or planning another pregnancy, and review whether it can stop later.

Conditional RecLow EvidenceATA 2017
6

Check TSH in any woman with new postpartum depression.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceACOG PB 223 2020
7

Continue methimazole up to 20 mg/day or propylthiouracil up to 750 mg/day during breastfeeding; these doses are not expected to affect infant thyroid function.

Moderate RecLow EvidenceATA 2026
SituationWhat to CheckWhenCommon Pitfall
On levothyroxineTSH (free T4 if needed)Every 4 weeks to about 20 weeks, then near 30 weeksForgetting to reduce the dose after delivery
On antithyroid drugsFree T4 (plus T3 if T3-predominant)Every 2–4 weeks early; 4–8 weeks after 20 weeksChasing a normal TSH and overtreating the fetus
Graves history, TRAb highTRAb/TSI; fetal ultrasoundFirst trimester, 18–22 weeks, 30–34 weeksAssuming ablated patients carry no fetal risk
Postpartum, after Graves or antibodiesTSH, free T46 weeks; 4–6 months; with any symptomsAttributing fatigue or low mood to the new baby
Clinical Pearl: In hyperthyroid thyroid disease in pregnancy treated with thioamides, the target is maternal free T4 at the top of the range — not a normal TSH. Pushing TSH into range usually means over-suppressing the fetal thyroid, which receives the same drug.2

Evidence in Context

How the guidelines and trials on thyroid disease in pregnancy line up.

Where ACOG, ATA 2026 and RCOG Agree▾

All three reject universal screening, treat overt hypothyroidism, target a TSH below 2.5 mU/L on treatment, favour propylthiouracil in the first trimester, and advise against levothyroxine for antibodies alone. ACOG formally endorsed the 2026 ATA guideline.

Where They Differ▾

ATA 2026 permits first-trimester treatment of subclinical hypothyroidism by shared decision; RCOG clearly recommends it only above a TSH of 10 mU/L; ACOG 2020 found no evidence of benefit. ACOG judged routine iodine supplementation unproven, whereas ATA 2026 advises it for all.

What the Trials Add▾

Every large levothyroxine trial — for subclinical disease after early pregnancy or for antibodies alone — has been negative; the positive signals come from small, early-treatment studies.

Evidence Gaps

These are the open questions in thyroid disease in pregnancy that clinicians meet in practice, where current advice rests largely on observational data or consensus.

  • Whether levothyroxine started early for mild thyroid disease in pregnancy in the first trimester for subclinical hypothyroidism improves any hard outcome remains untested in an adequately powered trial.
  • Risk-based TSH thresholds, rather than statistical reference intervals, have not been defined.
  • Whether to stay on propylthiouracil or switch to methimazole after the first trimester is unresolved.
  • Optimal free T4 targets on antithyroid drugs, and how to read a fetal goitre, lack good data.
  • Whether mild-to-moderate iodine deficiency harms child neurodevelopment, and whether supplementation prevents it, has not been proven in randomised trials.

References

  • 1.Korevaar TIM, Leung AM, Alexander EK, et al. American Thyroid Association 2026 guidelines for thyroid disease in preconception, pregnancy, and postpartum. Thyroid. 2026;36(5):481-544. https://doi.org/10.1177/10507256261445624
  • 2.American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Thyroid disease in pregnancy: ACOG Practice Bulletin, Number 223. Obstet Gynecol. 2020;135(6):e261-e274. https://doi.org/10.1097/AOG.0000000000003893
  • 3.Chan SY, Marsh MS, Gilbert J, et al. Management of thyroid disorders in pregnancy: Green-top Guideline No. 76. BJOG. 2025;132(8):e130-e161. https://doi.org/10.1111/1471-0528.18088
  • 4.Alexander EK, Pearce EN, Brent GA, et al. 2017 guidelines of the American Thyroid Association for the diagnosis and management of thyroid disease during pregnancy and the postpartum. Thyroid. 2017;27(3):315-389. https://doi.org/10.1089/thy.2016.0457
  • 5.Lazarus JH, Bestwick JP, Channon S, et al. Antenatal thyroid screening and childhood cognitive function. N Engl J Med. 2012;366(6):493-501. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1106099
  • 6.Casey BM, Thom EA, Peaceman AM, et al. Treatment of subclinical hypothyroidism or hypothyroxinemia in pregnancy. N Engl J Med. 2017;376(9):815-825. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1606205
  • 7.Dhillon-Smith RK, Middleton LJ, Sunner KK, et al. Levothyroxine in women with thyroid peroxidase antibodies before conception. N Engl J Med. 2019;380(14):1316-1325. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1812537
  • 8.Wang H, Gao H, Chi H, et al. Effect of levothyroxine on miscarriage among women with normal thyroid function and thyroid autoimmunity undergoing in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA. 2017;318(22):2190-2198. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2017.18249
  • 9.Alexander EK, Marqusee E, Lawrence J, et al. Timing and magnitude of increases in levothyroxine requirements during pregnancy in women with hypothyroidism. N Engl J Med. 2004;351(3):241-249. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa040079
  • 10.Yoshihara A, Noh J, Yamaguchi T, et al. Treatment of Graves’ disease with antithyroid drugs in the first trimester of pregnancy and the prevalence of congenital malformation. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2012;97(7):2396-2403. https://doi.org/10.1210/jc.2011-2860
  • 11.Ross DS, Burch HB, Cooper DS, et al. 2016 American Thyroid Association guidelines for diagnosis and management of hyperthyroidism and other causes of thyrotoxicosis. Thyroid. 2016;26(10):1343-1421. https://doi.org/10.1089/thy.2016.0229
  • 12.Athanasiadou KI, Peppa M, Kalantaridou SN, Paschou SA. Navigating the RCOG 2025 and ATA 2026 guideline updates on the management of thyroid disorders during pregnancy. Case Rep Womens Health. 2026:e00827. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crwh.2026.e00827

How to Read the Evidence Tags

Every recommendation carries a strength tag and an evidence tag — Medaptly’s own simplified reading of the underlying guidance, not a reproduction of any source body’s grading system.

Strength TagWhat It Means
Strong RecHigh-quality evidence broadly supports this action
Moderate RecThe weight of evidence favours this action
Conditional RecThe benefit is less certain — individualise
AgainstEvidence points to no benefit or potential harm
Evidence TagWhat It Means
High EvidenceMultiple well-designed trials or high-quality meta-analyses
Moderate EvidenceA single trial or large observational dataset
Low EvidenceExpert consensus or small studies

Article Information

For educational purposes only. This is original clinical education content informed by current published guidelines and clinical evidence. It does not constitute medical advice, is not endorsed by any guideline body, and does not replace individualised clinical judgement or local protocols. Verify all drug doses before prescribing, and consult the original source guidelines listed in the references.
The Medaptly Digest

Stay current in your specialty.

The evidence that moved practice this week — guideline shifts, landmark trials, and cases worth a second look — in a few high-yield minutes.

Free · One issue a week · Unsubscribe anytime

Which specialties?

Pick the ones you want — choose as many as you like.

Your newsletters

RELATED CONTENT

Explore More in This Specialty

Handpicked content from across articles, cases, research, guidelines, news, and presentations.

Loading related content...